November 19, 2026
At 1049 Main Street the pizza is thin enough to snap, and the cheese runs all the way to a browned edge. That is a South Shore bar pie. Boston Magazine's bar pizza guide calls it a regional style "native to the South Shore." The style began as a cheap snack to keep people at the bar, and it is built around small pies, cracker-like crusts and cheese that chars at the rim. The guide puts CRISP, the Walpole restaurant at that address, among the bar pie kitchens worth the drive.
A few hundred numbers back down Main Street, the pizza is a different thing. Supreme Pizza & Subs at 885 Main Street still lets you pick a traditional pan crust or an extra-thin, crispy one. Across town in East Walpole, Jimmy's has been baking Greek-style pizza since the 1990s. Out on High Plain Street, Sticks & Stones bakes in a wood fire.
Bar pie, Greek-style pan and wood-fired all have kitchens within a few miles of each other in 02081, so a good order starts with picking the style before you pick up the phone.
The clearest recent signal about Walpole pizza comes from the Hometown Best 2026 results, voted by readers of the Hometown Weekly newspapers. In the 2026 pizza category, the blue ribbon went to Royal Pizza in Medfield. CRISP took the red ribbon, and Rico's Pizzeria, also in Walpole, took the yellow. Two of the three ribbon winners in that regional category are Walpole kitchens, and they make different pizza.
CRISP is the bar pie. Boston Magazine names its owner as Robert Carnes, who worked at Venus Café before CRISP, and notes that he wants his pies to come out with browned edges. That guide was last updated in May 2024, so treat it as that year's pick, not a fresh ranking. CRISP was already running in Walpole by January 2021, when Boston Restaurant Talk reported its plans for a second location in Canton.
The Walpole location also has something Canton doesn't. CRISP's site lists a Fall/Winter menu that runs from September 16, 2026 into February 2027 at the Walpole restaurant only. The seasonal menu has two pies that stay on only through the season. The Maple Mustard Chicken has grilled chicken, bacon, caramelized onions and goat cheese under a maple-mustard drizzle. The Butternut Squash & Goat Cheese pairs roasted squash and caramelized onions with hot honey. The seasonal plates go well past pizza, with a French Onion Burger, Beef Pot Roast, Fall Steak Tips, Butternut Squash Ravioli and a Turkey Dinner. On a Thanksgiving weekend, that turkey entree is the kind of thing a house full of guests ends up ordering on Saturday.
Rico's Pizzeria, the yellow-ribbon winner, is at 1351 Main Street, near the far end of the Main Street run. It is family-owned, serves pizza alongside a broader Italian menu, takes online orders, and says on its site that it won #1 Hometown Best in 2024. Rico's is the pick when the table wants pizza and someone else wants a plate of Italian food.
Before bar pie had its own Boston Magazine guide, Walpole's pizza came mostly from family shops with long histories in town. The dates on those histories go back further than most people would guess.
Supreme Pizza & Subs carries the earliest date of the group. In 2013, Patch reported that Mike Alisandratos and his father bought the Walpole location in 1980, and that his mother and sister pitched in to run it. Today Supreme still sells specialty pizzas in that choice of traditional pan or extra-thin and crispy crust, and its posted hours include Sundays. If your household is split between people who want a pan crust and people who want something closer to bar pie, Supreme covers both on one order.
Jimmy's Pizza & Restaurant at 4 East Street is the East Walpole anchor. In 2016, Wicked Local profiled Themis and Athena Kalemkeridis, who opened Jimmy's in 1996 with help from Athena's parents and built it into a family business serving Greek-style pizza. Jimmy's own site lists takeout service, a phone number and hours, but its online ordering was paused when last checked, so calling is the dependable way to order. If you already spend weekends on the east side of town, Jimmy's fits the routine described in our East Walpole weekend guide.
Pizzeria Grande at 1185 Washington Street has a longer story than its sign suggests. In 2013, Patch profiled owner Doug Smith, who got into the restaurant business in 1998 and bought Grande after working there as a delivery driver and learning the other jobs in the shop. Grande's own site now describes it as family-owned under new ownership. It says the shop has served Walpole for over 30 years, makes classic Italian-style and specialty pies, and is open seven days a week.
Family Pizzeria at 637 Main Street is the furthest down Main of the shops here. Its menu is a classic neighborhood pizzeria's, Greek pizza included, with dine-in, pickup and delivery.
The third tradition has the newest feel, though it isn't new to pizza. Sticks & Stones at 514 High Plain Street bakes its pizza over wood and calls what it serves a Neapolitan pizza experience. It takes orders online.
Bianco's at 938 Main Street sits between the two. It advertises thin-crust, hearth-baked pizza, lists its hours, and delivers locally. In the stretch of Main Street from Supreme at 885 to CRISP at 1049, Bianco's puts a third crust within a short walk of the other two.
One more bar pie name has a Walpole connection, and it came through a shared kitchen, not a storefront. In May 2024, Destination Downtown Walpole listed Mike and Lenny's Bar Pizza among the tenants of the Gate House kitchen at 127 West Street. Casa De LaLa, ThankQue Barbeque, Wright Old School Chocolate, Real Food Ready to Eat and Royal Indian Kitchen were listed there too. A year later, Boston.com reported that Dave Portnoy reviewed Mike & Lenny's and gave it a 7.7 out of 10. The story described a setup of a Walpole ghost kitchen paired with a brick-and-mortar shop in Braintree. Mike & Lenny's own site lists its Braintree and Lakeville locations.
Put the three traditions side by side and the town's pizza map is easier to read than any single best-of list. The thin, browned-edge bar pie is at CRISP at 1049 Main Street, and its Walpole-only seasonal pies stay on the menu until February 2027. For Greek-style pizza from a shop with decades in town, the long-running family names are Jimmy's on East Street and Supreme on Main, and Pizzeria Grande on Washington Street and Family Pizzeria on Main also run house-of-pizza menus. A wood-fired pie means a drive out to Sticks & Stones on High Plain Street. Bianco's hearth-baked thin crust and Rico's broader Italian menu fill in between.
Most of these spots line one road. Family Pizzeria at 637, Supreme at 885, Bianco's at 938, CRISP at 1049 and Rico's at 1351 are all on Main Street. A pizza night downtown easily turns into a stop at the Common, the same corridor covered in our post on Tuesday nights on the Walpole Common. For the rest of the town's dining options, our guide to weekends in Walpole picks up where pizza leaves off.
For guests in town this week, the one pie they can't get back home is probably CRISP's, because the bar pie belongs to this part of Massachusetts.
If your favorite pizzeria is part of what makes your street feel like home, I'd love to hear which one it is. At Kiky Papadopoulos, we know the small routines of a town, like a Friday pizza order, count as much as square footage. If a move is anywhere on your horizon, I'm glad to talk about which part of town fits the way you live, down to the delivery zone. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Kiky today to discuss all your real estate needs!